Tagged: How slow?
May 11, 2020 at 6:26 pm #7848
How slow are runs supposed to be in zone 1? I’m barely moving and all the same keep ending up in zone 2, or, more often, zone 3. I’m wondering if I should just use perceived effort and not bother with the zones. I feel like I’m hardly getting any exercise! Is this what 80/20 should be?May 11, 2020 at 7:05 pm #7862
Scobie, first, let’s verify that your zones are correct:
1. Are you using Pace, Power or HR?
2. How did you test your zones?
3. What was the threshold result?
Zone 1 is pretty slow, but it usually is most difficult to maintain Zone 1 when using HR, as your HR will drift up over time. Pace and Power are more reliable. However, let’s first establish that your zones are solid.
DavidMay 12, 2020 at 7:07 am #7863
I’m using HR and it’s based on my maximum heart rate of 170. I didn’t test my zones otherwise. I admit I don’t know what my threshold result is. Looks like I need to do more work to get my zones right.May 12, 2020 at 8:20 am #7864
Scobie, yes, identifying threshold and establishing 80/20 zones might address your Zone 1 issue, but it will certainly improve your training overall.
See our documents Intensity Guidelines for Running or Triathlon to get started on identifying your zones. It’s possible that Zone 1 will still feel too low for HR, but then give Pace zones a try instead, as Pace can be more reliable.
DavidMay 12, 2020 at 8:39 am #7865
Thanks for your help, David. I’ll do that.May 18, 2020 at 8:43 pm #7893
How would I use power to assess my zones? I don’t quite understand the concept and can’t find it in 80/20 Running.May 18, 2020 at 8:59 pm #7894
Running power meters are relatively new, they did not exist when Matt wrote 80/20 Running in 2012.
To run with power, you need a running power meter, like a Stryd. Then, you would perform a threshold test using power instead of pace or HR. That testing protocol is found in the more modern book 80/20 Triathlon, or in our document Intensity Guidelines for Running.
Then, it’s similar to HR and Pace, in that you have a threshold Power value, say, 275 watts. Your 80/20 zones are then a % of that threshold as defined in the 80/20 Zone Calculator.
DavidMay 22, 2020 at 9:54 am #7900mgummerParticipant
Just on pace, I am using HR and can cruise along in zone 2 no problems until i hit a hill and my area has a few big hills. I can’t keep in Zone 2 up the hill no matter how I slow down unless I walk – the hills are pretty steep. Also my run from home starts with a big down hill which is fine in zone 1 but after 5 minutues when a foundation run switches to zone 2, I have to really go fast to get to zone 2 and then slow down again when it flattens – is this what I should be doing?
I have ordered a stryd so will switch to power when it comes and then I suppose it will be easier to maintain power – but I am assuming that will mean that my heart rate is probably still going up out of zone 2.
Appreciate your thoughts.
MattMay 23, 2020 at 10:13 am #7912
As much as I promote power over HR and Pace, it does not solve everything. It can’t “move mountains.” A steep hill will always be a steep hill, and as you have observed, a minimum level of intensity is required to run up some hills, and a minimum level of intensity is difficult to maintain on the descents.
While a power meter can give you better data to apply to your training, on hills that steep as you describe, you just need to do your best.
Give yourself permission to walk during recovery intervals if that’s what it takes to maintain Zone 1-2. For Foundation and Recovery runs, again, just do your best.
DavidMay 24, 2020 at 10:16 am #7921alanshrimptonParticipant
If I’m not mistaken you will get the same results running down a hill using power as you do with HR. I think you will still be running fast downhill to reach your power zone. One of the reasons why I haven’t gone down the power track. When I was running using HR I would revert to pace down hill. I found out the hard way by hurting my hamstring trying to reach my HR. Now I am using Pace the entire way but I use average pace so I can go a little slower up hills and match that by going a little faster down. It works for me.May 26, 2020 at 11:47 am #7939mgummerParticipant
great thanks David and Alan
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.